How can one explain the impossible to those unwilling to hear?
On the run from the blight, Jupiter has a surprising reunion, followed quickly by an even more surprising encounter.
As Jupiter navigates a tense new situation, Jefferson welcomes Ben Franklin and his apprentice, Fiona Pratt, to Monticello.
Wine and conversation flow freely, but something is amiss, and their revelries may soon come to an abrupt end.

PALE COLUMBIA STUDIO HEADQUARTERS
ALOYSIUS
Hello! I’m Doctor Aloysius Freeman –
ALLELLA
And I’m Professor Allella Marx-Parks –
ALOYSIUS
Welcome back to Pale Columbia. Our last episode ended with Jupiter Nameless – a mulatto slave of Thomas Jefferson –
ALLELLA
Ooooh, not the preferred nomenclature, dude. “Mulatto” comes from the Spanish for “mule.” You’re basically calling him an animal.
ALOYSIUS
That’s what they would’ve called him, dammit. What do you want me to –
ALLELLA
I’m just saying.
ALOYSIUS
There’s no time for this, Allella.We can’t afford to waste studio time on –
ALLELLA
Oh, Cassius’ll just edit this out. Ain’t that right, Cassius?
CASSIUS
You got it man.
ALLELLA
See? We’ll fix it in post. Just don’t call him a mule. In three. Two…
ALOYSIUS
With Jupiter Nameless, a multiracial person enslaved by Thomas Jefferson –
ALLELLA
There we go!
ALOYSIUS
Having encountered a horde of blighted colonists and made his escape, in the process leaving his companion, Samson, for dead. Meanwhile, Monticello had received a few new visitors of late, right Allella?
ALLELLA
That’s right. We’ll come back to Jupiter’s tale in a bit. but for now, let’s check in on Jefferson’s stately manse. Monticello had already welcomed one new arrival – the infamous slave mogul, Carmela Kaine – but there were two more just arriving. The first, you likely haven’t heard of: a nineteen-year-old printer’s apprentice by the name of Fiona Pratt. You’re more familiar with Miss Pratt’s mentor: the Founding Father by the name of Franklin. First name: Benjamin.
MONTICELLO GROUNDS
JEFFERSON
Doctor Franklin, as I live and breathe! Why, I’d wager my eyeteeth you haven’t aged a week since we last met –
FRANKLIN
Perhaps, but at my age, the days pass like dog years. Now, be a good lad and help an old man down, would you?
JEFFERSON
Of course. And might I assume this lovely specimen accompanying you –
FRANKLIN
Fiona’s my apprentice, yes, Thomas. But I’ve told her all about you, so calm your loins.
JEFFERSON
Why, Benjamin! I invite you into my home, and you repay me with calumny and aspersions? I’d hoped only that you would make introductions. She seems a fine lass, and she –
FIONA
Can introduce herself, Mister Jefferson. Fiona Pratt. And your companion?
JEFFERSON
Practiced and practical, this one is, Ben. I approve. I approve.
FIONA
Not that any approval was sought.
FRANKLIN
Fiona.
JEFFERSON
I mean only to say you seem the perfect apprentice to dear Benjamin, here. Efficient. No doubt, erudite –
FIONA
Well, I thank you, Mister Jeff –
JEFFERSON
Easy on the eye, as well.
FRANKLIN
Thomas –
KAINE
Perhaps your new guests, Jefferson, are weary from the road? Might we not relocate to somewhere less … musty?
JEFFERSON
Of course, forgive me! Benjamin, Fiona, allow me to introduce Carmela Kaine, of the Manassas Kaine's.
KAINE
Charmed, I’m sure.
JEFFERSON
Madam Kaine is here to purchase of a few of my negroes. She’d hardly settled in when word came of your approach. In my zeal to greet you, Ben, I may have pressed her into abandoning the comfort of the indoors.
KAINE
The heat is unpleasant, but I’d mostly prefer somewhere less redolent of … labor.
FIONA
I’ve heard of the Manassas Kaine's, Carmela –
KAINE
Madam Kaine, please. Miss, or mistress, if you must.
FIONA
And I’ve heard, Carmela, of your good fortune in growing your late husband’s estate.
KAINE
Yes, I’ve thrived where Thaddeus couldn’t –
FIONA
But do you mean to say you detest being in the presence of slaves, even as you draw your admittedly vast fortune from them?
KAINE
Were my livelihood built on trading cattle, Miss Pratt, should I then chew cud? If swine underpinned my fortune, would you have me muckwallow alongside them?
FIONA
These are neither cows nor sows, though, Carmela; but men. And women. So –
KAINE
Men and women with a place and a value, Miss Pratt. And seeing how Jefferson minds his house, men and women who know their station. Which is more than I can say for some.
JEFFERSON
Madam Kaine, I think, did have the right of it. It is rather hot out here. We might –
KAINE
I’ve heard tell of your efforts in support of emancipation, Franklin. Given your apprentice’s comportment, I can only assume you support the erasure of all natural hierarchies among men.
FRANKLIN
A clever acquaintance of mine did once write, “All men are created equal.” Fiona may be brash now and then, but she has a good head on her.
KAINE
I’m sure. And am I to take it you’ve no compunctions regarding what might be said of you traveling alone with a young woman?
FRANKLIN
My dear, at my age, one must be grateful when people say anything about something you’re doing, as that means you’re still alive.
JEFFERSON
Ha! Yes, well said, old friend. Now, as I was saying: Cooler environs might yield cooler heads, no? Let’s away now!
JEFFERSON
She’s a fine filly, I’ll attest, Benjamin, but I need you to corral her. I can ill afford to lose this sale on account of another of your libertine lasses.
FRANKLIN
Oh hush, Thomas. Birds must fly, fish must swim, and hens must peck. Just sit back and enjoy nature. Fiona is a fascinating specimen. And speaking of fascinating specimens, is Jupiter about? I’m of a mind to play some chess.
JEFFERSON
Ah, Jupiter. Well, I regret to inform you…
THE WILDERNESS
ALOYSIUS
Meanwhile, Jupiter had met the limits of his book learning. Avoiding roads, he’d found himself lost, incapable of navigating a –
JUPITER
Godforsaken wilderness. Come on, Jupiter! You can play a sonata and recite Hamlet simultaneously. How hard could it be to find a cardinal direction?
JUPITER
How’s the line go? “I am but mad north-north-west”? Not that I can find either. Now, the moss. It grows on which side of a tree? Who told me that? Ah. Hercules. Doubtless, now, he’s in a dozen pieces; sliced and studied to slake some sawbones’ curiosity. Could be he’s better off than me: aimless, adrift, unable to walk a road for fear of rabid horde or slave catcher. I should have grabbed a compass. Damn you, Jupiter, you should have grabbed a compass. Back at Percival’s general store. Before-- before Samson.
SAMSON
You. Shouldn’t talk. So goddamn loud Nameless.
JUPITER
Samson! How did you –
SAMSON
Shouldn’t be so loud if you ain’t trying to get caught.
JUPITER
Samson, you look a wreck. I –
SAMSON
Course I do, Nameless! You left me to die!
JUPITER
They were coming, so I –
SAMSON
Had to save your own ass, huh? Look at you. Got turned around. Ended up. Back where you came.
JUPITER
Back where I came? I’ve been walking for an eternity! The moss. I –
SAMSON
Idiot. How you think I caught up with you? You got turned around. Main road ain’t but a stone’s throw away. All that book learning, but still. Goddamn fool.
JUPITER
Samson! Dear God, you’re burning up! I’m going to get you back home. I just need to remember. Like Hercules said. The moss –
METHOD
The north side. Moss grows on the north side of a tree.
REDD
Not that you need worry about none of that no more. We know how to get you back home.
LILLIAN METHOD
Lillian Method
My name is Lillian, but most everyone calls me Method. The gentleman to your left, aiming a musket at your feverish companion, is my associate, Arch Porter. Say hello, Arch.
ARCH
Ugly business, slave hunting. But a man’s got to make a living. Please don’t think –
METHOD
Arch.
ARCH
Hello.
METHOD
And the burly, redheaded woman holding the blade to your back, that’s my partner, Gertrude.
REDD
Ain’t never had much use for my Christian. You can call me Redd.
METHOD
Of course, we’re here to return you to your owner. And on that note, thanks: If not for your soliloquy, we might have missed you.
REDD
Believe that’s what the learned folk call “fortuitous.”
METHOD
Indeed, dearest.
JUPITER
Look, Miss – Method? I don’t know who you think we are, but –
METHOD
I think you’re a “red-haired mulatto aged nineteen,” while your friend is a “darker black buck of sturdy build.” That is: just the lads we were sent to find, and it’s a bit insulting that you’d try to convince me otherwise. Don’t insult me, Jupiter.
JUPITER
But if you’ll just hear me out! Back there! Something’s wrong back in that town –
REDD
Well, ain’t we just fortuitous that we’re not heading back there.
METHOD
Indeed. Now, be a good lad and hold out your hands so Gertrude can fit those manacles. If your friend doesn’t stop moaning, we’ll have to gag him, but if you’re quiet, you can avoid his fate.
JUPITER
You don’t understand! This blight! They’re rabid! One bit Samson! We have to –
METHOD
I did try to be magnanimous.
REDD
You always do, love.
METHOD
Bind and gag the two of them.
ARCH
This one might not make it. Fever and all.
METHOD
So we’ll make haste and get them back before he expires. Binds and bridles, Arch. I’ll go fetch the wagon.
ROAD TO MONTICELLO
METHOD
I swear by Nature and Nature’s God, boy, if you won’t be silent, you’ll make a roadside feast for the buzzards while we tell your master we could only find your friend.
REDD
And I’ll snip your half-blood bollocks afore we’re done with ya; see if it’s true mulattos got one black ball and one white.
ARCH
Redd, that’s absurd.
REDD
What? I heard it out west, Arch. I swear. You recall that surgeon –
ARCH
Redd, for the love of Christ –
REDD
The one we took all them dead savage bodies to. He said the blacks and the savages got bigger balls, all animalistic-like. And he said the insides match the outsides. And if you mix them –
METHOD
Redd. Gertrude. Dearest – and you, too, Arch – Might not the two of you let silence reign these last few miles?
REDD
I was only saying that, with a white father? Black or red mother? It’d make sense that –
REDD
Quiet, you!
ALLELLA
To Method’s chagrin, Redd and Porter only managed about an hour of silence.
MONTICELLO
ALLELLA
Fortunately for her, they soon arrived at Monticello. As they approached the estate’s outer perimeter, an overeager overseer spotted them, delegated his charge to the nearest slave, and sped off on horseback to inform Jefferson of their arrival. Redd, Method, and Arch continued on, curious slaves stopping to gawk and tag along. By the time Jefferson emerged from the main house to meet them, they had drawn a crowd.
SLAVE BYSTANDER 1
Bet that yella boy got timid and snitched.
SLAVE BYSTANDER 2
Ain’t even make it two steps before you started itching for wine and big words with Massa, ain’t that right, Nameless?
METHOD
That’s enough of that. You lot want to handle the boy yourselves, and that’s just fine. Just wait until we’ve got cash in hand. Try anything before that, and well…
REDD
Gaggle of willful types you got tilling your fields, Jefferson.
JEFFERSON
Think not for a moment that their impertinence slipped my sight. Back to work, all of you, lest you pass the night with empty bellies!
JEFFERSON
Now, on to happier matters. I’m told the shepherds have retrieved a pair of wayward sheep.
REDD
Billygoats is more like it, for all the bleating they done. The blacker buck –
METHOD
Samson, I believe you call him. He was injured prior to our apprehending him. It worsened during our trip and – to spare all of our sanities – we gagged him to muffle his moaning.
REDD
And the mulatto was chattering about rabid folk –
METHOD
Some imagined horrors preceding their capture. We gagged him as well. I suspect some fever has racked his faculties, but you will note that we’ve delivered both fugitives whole and alive. Now, as to the matter of our pay –
JEFFERSON
Has she the right of it, Jupiter? Are you yet addled by some persistent calenture?
ARCH
His main concern, Mister Jefferson, has been his companion. As to Samson’s wound –
REDD
Stinks to high Heaven, it does. Probably lose that foot. Keep him from running again, at least –
ARCH
Redd, please. Now , I’m no proper physic, but if you’ve the means to bleed him –
JEFFERSON
Our physician is away. I suppose Samson will do penance this night. You there!
MALE SLAVE
Yessuh?
JEFFERSON
Convey Samson to the slave quarters. See that he receives light punishment and have someone prepare a poultice for that abscess.
MALE SLAVE
Yessuh!
METHOD
Not to belabor the matter, but regarding our pay –
JEFFERSON
I’d intended to discourse on that matter presently. At the moment, I am – how to put it? – Rather illiquid. If you three would but tarry until the morrow –
METHOD
Jefferson, our contract stipulated –
JEFFERSON
Of course, of course! And I intend to make good. I have another guest tonight with whom I’ve impending business. Once we’ve reified that transaction, you can expect remuneration tout suite!
REDD
Bunch of big words, but you look like you’re offering an IOU. You better make good, Jefferson.
JEFFERSON
Sesquipedalian as my supplication might be –
REDD
What you call me?
JEFFERSON
I promise! Madam please, there’s no need to produce knives. I was just saying I promise. You’ve my word, I assure you. Now, if there’s nothing else –
ARCH
Sir, I believe the lad’s injury –
JEFFERSON
Doubtless a passing matter. The Negro, you see, is made of sturdy stuff. Where he wants for mental acuity, he abounds in fortitude. Samson will be fine. Meanwhile, tonight, we’ll have fine wine to drink and finer linens to rest on. All the while, our returned prodigal, Jupiter, shall entertain us. Isn’t that right, Jupiter?
JUPITER
(Protests fiercely through gag)
JEFFERSON
Exactly. He’s a fine specimen. A tribute to his race. But where was I? Ah, yes – the Negro. Though distasteful, their bondage is necessary for their betterment. Imagine, if you will, the Negro some decades hence…
MONTICELLO DINING ROOM
FRANKLIN
Have to admit the contradiction, Thomas. You speak of making this continent into – how did you call it? It was something hopelessly lyrical –
JEFFERSON
An Empire of Liberty.
FRANKLIN
Yes, there it is. Seductive and sonorous, those words. Silky, even. But one might as well wipe one’s ass with said silk if that empire –
(burps)
Er … where was I?
FIONA
You were deriding the notion of an Empire of Liberty founded on bondage.
FRANKLIN
Yes, Fiona! Now, Thomas—
FIONA
Though if you ask me—
KAINE
Not that anyone did.
FIONA
I’d be interested to hear Jupiter’s thoughts on the matter.
JEFFERSON
Jupiter’s thoughts? Miss Pratt, I’m afraid you’ve—
FIONA
Well he’s delighted us all this eve on the pianoforte, has he not? Might we not free him from that inhuman bridle gag.
FRANKLIN
Oh Yes, Fiona! You squeeze a delectable grape, Thomas. The wine bested me for a moment. Pour me another, would you?
FIONA
Given that you’ve only just recovered from your most recent gout attack, sir, might I advise you against another glass? Your attacks do come on fast, so why risk further agony?
FRANKLIN
Yes, Fiona, the gout is indeed hell. And having just walked through hell, I see no need to start stepping lightly.
JEFFERSON
I see your point, Ben, and – sometime after we’ve resolved this conflict with the Crown – I’d imagine large-scale manumission is inevitable, but –
KAINE
Inevitable? Heaven forfend! You would saddle us by letting the blacks live among us?
JEFFERSON
Among us? No. We’d doubtless send them off –
KAINE
If that’s your thinking, Jefferson, it’s a blessing that I came here.
FIONA
And why did you come here exactly, Carmela?
FRANKLIN
Fiona.
KAINE
I’d come intending to add a portion of Jefferson’s bondsmen to my own holdings, Miss Pratt. Seeing now that he aims to unleash them among us –
JEFFERSON
I’ve no intention of them living among us!
KAINE
I’m almost of a mind to purchase all of his human capital, thus sparing civilization from his folly.
FIONA
So you traveled here alone, carrying enough money to buy – how many slaves?
KAINE
Alone? Hardly. My coachman dines as we speak with my intended purchases. As to traveling with currency, well – You’ll never be in a position to confirm this, Miss Pratt, but when you reach a certain level of wealth, you need not carry large sums on you, as your word carries its weight in gold. I came to inspect Jefferson’s merchandise, and I’ve found them to my liking. Funds will be exchanged in the future.
JEFFERSON
I’m sorry, am I to understand you’ve brought no funds with you? Not even enough for a down payment, perhaps? It’s just that I’m rather illiquid at the moment, and I’d intended to use a portion of the proceeds to pay –
METHOD
Pardon, I was distracted for a second, now did I mishear, or
REDD
You heard right.
(Burps)
You serve a fine steak, Jefferson. Wine’s good, too. Still gonna cut you if you don’t pay up, but the wine’s pretty damn good.
JEFFERSON
I assure you, my friends, I – Madam Kaine, not even a bit of pocket--
(Sighs)
Let me think. Jupiter, God damn it, play something else so I can think!
ARCH
Forgive my interjection, sir, but speaking of Jupiter, I’m reminded of Samson. I was wondering if maybe –
METHOD
Forget the slave, Arch. We need to get paid.
REDD
Ain’t no wine left in this bottle. Hey, Ben, pass me the one you just opened!
ARCH
But, sir, if I may – the boy’s abscess –
JEFFERSON
Of course! Madams Redd and Method, you’re in possession of a prison wagon.
REDD
Oh, this wine is fantastic!
JEFFERSON
Madam Kaine, you’ve already decided which of my slaves you’d like to buy. Why not load those slaves into Redd and Method’s wagon, whereupon they travel to Manassas with you? Once there, you can pay them their fee out of our settled price. Then they return the remainder to me here!
METHOD
Our agreement didn’t include ferrying funds for you.
JEFFERSON
And what if I threw in a bonus of, say, fifteen percent?
REDD
You throw in some of them steaks, a few crates of wine, we’ll bring your money back.
JEFFERSON
Done.
ARCH
Sir, not to belabor the point, but –
JEFFERSON
Oh, for God’s sake, fine! Go examine Samson to your heart’s content! Sleep among the slaves for all I care! Gideon!
GIDEON
Sir?
JEFFERSON
Escort Mister Arch to the slave quarters or wherever he wants to go! Just so long as he’s out of here!
FRANKLIN
Thomas?
JEFFERSON
What?
FRANKLIN
Let’s get that muzzle off Jupiter, eh? The boy’s learned his lesson, and I’ve a mind to challenge him over the chessboard.
JEFFERSON
I’d make a better opponent. Aside from two early wins as he was learning the game, I’ve beaten him every time.
FRANKLIN
A fact I take to mean that the transitive property is well within your blindspot.
JEFFERSON
What’s that?
FRANKLIN
Nothing, dear Thomas. Madam Redd, might you have the key to that apparatus? Come, Jupiter. Tell me, have you tried out the Ruy Lopez as I suggested last time?
SLAVE QUARTERS
GIDEON
Mister Porter, sir, they’re expecting me back in the kitchen, so if you’ll grant –
ARCH
Hopefully, I won’t be too long, and – Good lord, I can smell the wound from here!
GIDEON
Mister Porter, sir, this doesn’t feel right. They look scared, and –
ARCH
Of course they’re scared. Do you hear his breathing? Ragged as a consumption patient. They likely fear your insufferable fop of a master will blame them if the boy dies. Make way, let me examine – My God, he’s scalding to the touch! How long has he been spasming so? And why has no one removed the bridle?
GIDEON
They don’t have a key, sir.
ARCH
The mechanism’s simple enough, it’s just – Bugger it. Who has a nail?
ARCH
My holy God! Someone help me hold him down!
ARCH
Agh! My Arm! Oh no. Oh God no. Gideon, wait!
PALE COLUMBIA STUDIO HEADQUARTERS
ALOYSIUS
The night is deepening, and the blight is rising at Monticello, so we hope you’ll join us next time. We’ll pick up right where we left off with the next episode of … Pale Columbia.

#FightTheBlight